Modded rules out the two easy answers. Realms, Mojang's own rental, is US$7.99 a month and allows no mods or plugins at all. And since Java 26.2 the old "Open to LAN" is a "Multiplayer options" screen with two scopes, Off and Local — the online, peer-to-peer option that was in the snapshots was pulled before release ("not ready in its current form"), so for now a world you open is reachable on your own network and nowhere else. Reaching it from the internet means port forwarding, which the Minecraft wiki's own server tutorial pairs with a warning about griefers scanning public addresses.
So the real options are mods and apps that make the tunnel for you. Four of them do, and they differ on three questions that decide your evening:
- Who has to be online for the world to exist?
- What do your friends install?
- Who keeps the mods in sync — because a modded world is only joinable with the same loader, the same mods, compatible versions, on every PC?
1. Essential
Essential is a client mod (Fabric, Forge, NeoForge; Minecraft 1.8, 1.12 and 1.16 onwards) with a friends list, cosmetics and a Host button. You open a singleplayer world, press Host, and friends join from the Essential friends list. Hosting is free; the paid part is cosmetics.
- Who is online: you. The wiki says it straight — the host "needs to be online because they act as the server". Close the game and the world is gone until you are back. Up to 8 players at once.
- What friends install: joining goes through Essential's own friends list and Join button, so in practice Essential on their side too, plus an official Mojang-authenticated account; the mod does not run on offline accounts.
- The mods: your call. Modded worlds work when everyone has the same mods in their mods folder as the host. Essential checks nothing about that; a friend with one jar missing fails at join like on any server.
- Worth knowing: Essential collects what it calls functionally required data (username, UUID, friends, messages, purchases) with no opt-out; analytics are optional; it says it never sells any of it.
Verdict: the smoothest "tonight" option for vanilla or a small mod set everyone already has. It does nothing about the mod list, and the world lives in your hours.
2. e4mc
e4mc is a one-sided tunnel: install it on the host (Fabric, Forge, NeoForge, Quilt), open your world to LAN, and a public address appears next to the port. Friends paste that address into Direct Connect like any server.
- Who is online: you — your open world is still the server.
- What friends install: nothing. "You don't need to install e4mc on both sides" is the mod's own line. That makes it the easiest one to get a non-modding friend into.
- The mods: your call, same as Essential — same mods in every folder, checked by nobody.
- Worth knowing: it is MIT-licensed with the relay's source public, and every byte goes through that relay, so ping depends on it.
Verdict: the least friction for the friends. Nothing for the mods, nothing for the world when you log off.
3. World Host
World Host (Fabric, Forge, NeoForge, Quilt) is a client mod that tries
to open the port on your router by itself (UPnP) and falls back to a
proxy when the router refuses. Friends with the mod see your world in a
friends list; friends without it get an address from /worldhost ip
(through the proxy, "may increase ping") or a temporary one from
/worldhost tempip.
- Who is online: you.
- What friends install: the mod, for the friends list; without it, the address route works.
- The mods: your call, checked by nobody.
- Worth knowing: when UPnP succeeds you are directly reachable, which is the fast path and also a port that is open to anyone who finds it, while your world is open.
Verdict: between the two above — direct when the router plays along, a relay when not. Same silence on mods and on the world's hours.
4. Game Hangout
Game Hangout is not a mod; it is an app on each PC that runs the real Fabric dedicated server for one of you and tunnels the others in. It is ours, so read it as such.
- Who is online: whoever starts it. The world is a snapshot that follows the players: when the host leaves, the app offers the world to whoever stays, and the next person to press Start continues where it was. The group gets the always-on feeling without a bill. The honest limit: when the last person logs off, the game is off until somebody starts it.
- What friends install: the app, and their own Minecraft. They join from the app; nothing is pasted, nothing is forwarded, and the first start asks once for admin rights because it creates a real network adapter.
- The mods: this is the part the other three leave to you. The mod list is picked from Modrinth — in the app, or in the browser with friends, before anyone installs anything — and shared in the session, so everyone runs the same set without sending jars around. Missing dependencies — Fabric API, the config libraries — are spotted before the server starts, one button adds them. And when a mod still breaks the server, the built-in bisect starts it with half the list, then half of that, until it names the one.
- Worth knowing: Windows only, Fabric only, Java Edition only. The host downloads the server once (it is small). Your ping is your internet.
Verdict: the only one of the four that does the mod list and the world's hours; the price is an app instead of a mod, and Windows.
Side by side
| Host must be online | Friends install | Keeps mods in sync | Price | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Essential | yes | Essential + Mojang account | no | free (cosmetics paid) |
| e4mc | yes | nothing | no | free |
| World Host | yes | the mod, or use an address | no | free |
| Game Hangout | somebody, not you | the app | yes — list shared, dependencies checked, bisect | free |
| Realms, for comparison | no | nothing | no mods allowed | US$7.99/month |
Or let the app do it
Pick your mods in the app, press Start, friends join with the same list, and when you go to bed the world goes to whoever is still on. If one mod breaks the server, you read a sentence that names it instead of a log. That is the whole pitch, and the trade is on the homepage next to the download.